Dad and Ben by Kirsten Nash
Last week Mother and Mr. Barton got married. That’s what they told us anyway. I wasn’t actually there. It was what they call a civil ceremony, no church. Then they went away on a honeymoon somewhere, but I don’t think it was in another country. Just over to Vancouver or somewhere close to it. It all happened kind of quickly, so I wasn’t really sure where they’d gone, but Ben and me were holding down the fort there at Barton’s Berry Farm on our own. Except for Mrs. Grimes, who came two or three times a week to help clean and cook up some stews and soups for us. Mrs. Grimes also happened to make the best lemon meringue pie in the world, and she wasn’t too shy to bring one for us when Mother wasn’t there to make it a competition.
I was sitting under the magnolia tree churning some butter in our hand-crank churner and thinking that the next time I would see Mr. Barton I’d be calling him Dad like he told me I could. Mr. Barton (Abe)(Dad) told me I could call him whatever I liked until I was comfortable with him being my Daddy. It’s not like there’s anyone else on deck to be my father, and as I’ve said before, Mr. Barton has a kindness in him. I don’t recall asking for much more in a father or anyone else.
There wasn’t much for Ben and me to do. It was the end of August and everything you do on a berry farm is usually done before then. We finished mulching the fields with hay, and except for tending to a few late tomatoes, and of course the broccoli, cabbage, onions and potatoes, there was not much to do in the vegetable garden. Mother said we’d be canning when they got back because she found a bunch of cobwebbed old mason jars in the basement under the stairs. I wasn’t sure what we’d be canning, and I don’t think she was either, but I was sure she’d find something. Then, most likely, she’d do the first batch and go on and on about how fulfilling it is to be living off the land, then get bored and leave me with the next ten batches of whatever we were canning to do on my own.
Ben had gotten over his moodiness. Matter of fact, a few weeks before this one, when Mr. Barton and Mother decided to get married, we had a jam session in the living room! Turns out Mr. Barton plays clarinet! So Ben got his acoustic guitar and Mr. Barton got his clarinet and they started playing all these old blues songs and I just hummed along quietly. Mother was dancing, one hand on her hip and the other balancing a martini. Ben and Mr. Barton had had a few beer and they were laughing and telling jokes while they played. Sometimes they laughed and made jokes with the music. I got the jokes but Mother didn’t. She was up too high on her martini cloud, lost in her hips gyrating, her soul reaching out to reclaim a lost dream with a clawed and desperate hand.
While Mother was swaying, Mr. Barton came over beside her and started playing this snake charmer music like I heard on the Bugs Bunny Hour once when Bugs was hiding in a snake basket and Elmer Fudd was trying to hunt him down. Trying, because no one ever did catch Bugs Bunny. He was quick and clever and funny and didn’t mind showing his feminine side off in a flowery dress if it meant getting away from the Tasmanian Devil. Actually Bugs was pretty quick to put on a dress if you ask me, and that had me wondering sometimes. I asked Ben about it one Saturday morning after the chores were done when we were both sitting on the couch eating our cereal and watching the Bugs Bunny Road Runner Hour. Do you think Bugs Bunny is gay?
Ben just about spat his cereal all over the coffee table. Where do you get ideas like that at your age? Of course Bugs Bunny isn’t gay! He’s a cartoon!
I kept looking at the television, enjoying his reaction. He wears dresses a lot and is always shaking his fluffy tail at everyone. And he lives alone in a little hole, no Mrs. Bugs. I don’t think I’ve ever seen him go out on a date unless he was dressed up like a woman!
Ben just shook his head and got up. You’re a strange one! He headed to the kitchen, as I wondered out loud if there was a little more to the Tom and Jerry story than they were saying too.
Mother’s eyes were closed and she was gyrating and jerking to the clarinet’s taunting as Ben stopped playing his guitar and watched his Dad and my Mother drift off in their boozy dream. Ben’s gaze was on them and my eyes squinted at Ben from the corner of the couch, where I was cuddled up with an old crocheted throw pretending to be asleep. It was late, and I probably should have been in bed, but I figured all three of them had stopped noticing me about an hour ago. I was in no hurry to leave.
Ben stood up with his guitar, slowly, stretching and yawning elaborately, he announced, I’m tired. I’m goin’ to bed. The snake charmer and his bride to be didn’t seem to notice as Ben held his guitar in one hand and easily scooped me up off the sofa with the other. Come on sis-to-be! It’s bedtime for you too. He threw me over his big, tall shoulder and carried me to my room, dumping me on the bed like a sack of spuds. I still pretended to be asleep until he started tickling me and then all was lost. I giggled and tried to tickle him back but his long, long arms turned my attempts into a romp with futility.
Good night Ben, I whispered when he had finished tickling me and was heading to my door, turning the light out on the way. He stopped, massive in the doorframe. The bright hall light behind him darkened his front and made him look kind of spooky, but when he smiled that all went away. Ben had the best smile. He would never need a clarinet to charm a snake. Just one smile and Ben had the world kissing his fingers.
‘Night, kid, and he turned away and closed the door. I heard his footsteps disappear into his room and the click of his door and then all was quiet. Mother and Abe were done with their show and although there were two beds in my room and one of them was for my mother as far as the neighbours were concerned, I didn’t think I would be seeing her in it that night.
…………………………………
The butter started to lump up on the wooden paddle and the buttermilk I had bashed out of it swished against the glass jar until solid and liquid were completely parted. I stood up halfway and ducked out from under the tree to see Abe’s old blue truck coming around the bend in the driveway. I could see my Mother waving, with a new scarf knotted under her chin and new red, red lipstick pasted around her teeth. Abe was laughing and waving too.
Ben came out onto the front step, with his shirt off. He’d been working on his truck out back behind the garage, and was wiping some grease off his hands with a blue towel. They pulled up in front of the garage and Mother waited for Abe to get out and come around to open her door. She stepped out slowly so as to best model her new strappy high heels. Gone was the school marm dress. Mother was back to her natural fashion inclinations, and I felt a sense of relief in that. At least I knew who she was again.
Abe was still smiling, but he was looking at Ben with a pass of clouds in his eyes. Where’s your respect Ben? Get a shirt on boy! But Mother was already up the stairs, hugging Ben, grease and all. That’s ok Ben, it’s great to see you! And where’s my little girl? Oh there you are! Come and give your Mother a hug! I put down the butter churn on the edge of the front stairs and braced myself as she teetered over to hug me.
She insinuated herself upon me then just as abruptly switched courses and clicked her way up the wooden stairs, her shoes challenging gravity and into the house then back out again, giggling like a school girl. Oh I guess I just completely forgot to let you carry me over the threshold Abe! I am so sorry! OK! I’ll wait here for you an’ you come an’ lift me up like you would, you know, with a new wife! Mother was almost feverish, like maybe if she believed hard enough she could be good enough to really love Abe, she would.
Ben stepped past her and back into the house. I heard the back screen door slam and figured he’d gone back to his truck. Abe…Dad…smiled up at my mother who was curtsying coyly on the front landing and with a couple of long strides he was swooping her up in his arms and she was squealing and giggling and then they disappeared into the house leaving me and the butter churn on the landing to watch them get swallowed up by the hallway leading to what would now be officially their room.
The door clicked shut, the giggles faded. I took the butter churn into the kitchen, dumped out the buttermilk into a jug and then scraped the butter off the paddles and into a dish. I decided to salt and pat the excess moisture out of it later, because the house suddenly seemed too quiet to feel comfortable. The refrigerator door squeaked as I put the jug on a shelf and the butter beside it. I left the butter churn on the counter and watched out the back window as Ben crossed the yard, his shirt on this time, and shut himself up in the shed.
It seemed like a good time to go to my fort.
Snuggled up to our driveway was a strip of forest about two hundred feet wide that cut back from the road like a big green band-aid joining us to the fields next door. I didn’t know who owned it, didn’t much care. I never saw anyone there so I became its’ warden, soaking up the scents of the ferns and the thick-lipped fungi fused with rusty barked trunks as I stepped over the fallen logs working my way deeper into the thicket. There was a deer path running through the core of the cedars, firs, and molting cottonwoods, and near the road the ragged, chaffed maple trees poked out of the white-berried scrub to greet people in the spring and surprise them every autumn with their flashes of lime, crimson and fire.
Mossy twigs snapped under my bare feet. Although even then I appreciated the finer aesthetics of shoe wear, I preferred not to actually wear the shoes, especially in the summer. In the winter I even liked the feeling of the crystallized snow crunching beneath and between my toes, but not for too long. Most of the summer I had been barefoot except when milking our pretty Jersey cow, Josephine, who was apt to step on your toes just before she lifted a caramel leg up and stomped it down petulantly in the bucket. You just hoped that happened at the beginning of the milking instead of when you were almost finished stripping the last teat.
I got to name her when my mother and Abe had her delivered at the beginning of summer, just after we moved in. Mother liked the name when I came up with it because she was thinking that I was getting it from Empress Josephine, Napoleon’s wife, but I was actually thinking of Josephine Baker, the “Black Venus” of jazz. I didn’t bother correcting her. We didn’t often have the same ideas about things.
In a couple of minutes I was at one of my favorite spots with deeply fern-clad carpets of cool moss and mulch soothing my calloused feet. Over the summer I had meticulously cleared the area that I stood in now of prickly things and poking sticks. I pulled rocks from their cedar dropping nests and made them into walls. I spent hours dragging large branches, dropped jagged off their wind worn hosts, from all over the woods to lean them against each other in Seussian shapes and then wove smaller branches and ferns all over them to discourage the rain.
Ben had taken to calling me after a Hobbit because of my bare feet and the fact that I spent almost all my spare time after the chores were done in my fort. Hey Bilbo! he would call out from the back porch, Supper’s ready! He’d stand there and laugh at me as, I scrambled out, my hair wild and peppered with twigs and leaf bits, from a hole I had pruned between an overgrown holly bush and the scraggly cedar hedging that Abe had planted when he first bought the place. When Ben’s mom was still alive. I wondered if Abe had carried her across the threshold and if she had giggled until the bedroom door closed like my mother had. Abe would have looked more like Ben then, not much older either.
On hot summer mornings I would get up early, before it got too hot, to milk Josephine, because although Mother really enjoyed the idea of fresh, non-pasteurized milk from our very own cow, after the first few milkings she lost her enthusiasm for that part of the process. So the milking of Josephine was added to the rest of my daily chores, which included twice daily feedings and weekly pen mucking of the chickens, turkeys, ducks, pigs, all installed on Barton’s Berry Farm in the past few months as a result of some whim or another of my Mother’s. And all were passed on to me to care for once the novelty wore off for her.
After the chores were done, I would get myself some cereal or cinnamon toast then head off to my fort with a book. There, with a cushion of leaves in a cavern I had carved out of the peat and moss I would get lost in dreams and possibilities, adventures and betrayals, love and it’s inevitable flipside of madness as sunshine leaked through the leafy canopy and pooled, mottled with shadows on the pages and all around me.
Ben liked to read too, science fiction and epic books like the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings, or anything by Hemingway. And he collected guitar magazines. He had tons of Guitar Player magazines. Mother borrowed one and said she wanted to learn how to play guitar when she got back from the honeymoon. She asked Ben if he’d teach her and he more grunted than replied. It seemed funny to me that when Ben and me were alone together we could talk and talk about things and he was funny and charming, and then as soon as Mother would come into the room, he’d clam up tight and found his own feet a lot more interesting than her face. When he did look up I thought he looked more like he was trying not to laugh than anything, as he shuffled his feet and chewed on the inside of his face where the lower cheek and bottom lip met.
You know, Ben, you could make some extra money teachin’ the kids around River’s End guitar in that old shed of yours out in the back! I bet you could charge twenty dollars a lesson! And you could get them to pay you in cash so you wouldn’t have to claim it on your income tax…
Ben was at the kitchen table a few days ago when she came up with that one. He almost spat out his chicken pot pie. No one’s gonna drive all the way out here for guitar lessons! Besides, I got enough to do with the farm to be thinkin’ about somethin’ like that. He took a long drink of his water and then a bite of mashed potatoes and broccoli, putting a great deal of concentration into his chewing.
Well I think they’d come, especially those kids from your old high school…they all looked up to you so much! Mother sat down across from Ben and next to me, her plate hitting the table about the same time as her rear end hit her chair seat. She was wearing a low-slung peasant blouse and push-up bra over a pair of white cotton Capri pants and white Keds, her version of farm-wear. As she leaned forward elaborately to pick up the salt, putting her best faces forward, I couldn’t help but notice Ben’s face redden and his half-eaten plate become even more interesting than his shoes had ever been.
Abe had gone overnight to a berry grower’s convention in Victoria. I couldn’t believe they had such a thing, but he told me that was where he would be ordering next year’s new crop. He liked to rotate the crops, and bring in new plants every couple of years to discourage pests from figuring out ahead of time where they would be feeding on the next year.
It was the first time the three of us had been alone in the house. Mother had made a big deal of saying goodbye to Abe, kissing him on the front porch longer than Ben and me were comfortable with as we stood by in the living room to wave goodbye from the window. But as Abe’s truck turned from the driveway onto the road, Mother took a deep breath, smiling to herself as she exhaled and walked into the kitchen to pour her self a cup of coffee. Adding some brandy from Abe’s liquor cabinet she announced to no one in particular, I’m going back to bed.
When she reappeared just before lunchtime, she was fully made up, hair curled and sprayed and happier than I’d seen her in months. I was about to make myself a peanut butter sandwich when she breezed into the kitchen. I’ve got a great idea! Why don’t we put together a picnic for the three of us and drive to the beach for lunch?
I looked up at her, incredulous, untrusting. Who are you and what have you done with my mother?
She ignored me as she went about taking out sandwich meats and cheese from the refrigerator. Why don’t you run and tell Ben to come in for a minute?
No matter how many times she let me down, I always held out hope that one day my mother would be like other people’s mothers. She would love me and take me to the mall for girl’s days out, or sign me up for Brownies and put herself up as a den mother! As I ran out the kitchen door I couldn’t help but feel that maybe this was a turning point. Now that Mother was married to Mr. Barton, she might have enough happiness in her life, maybe so much that she could share some of it with me.
Ben was head-first in his engine again when I got to his truck, it’s red and rusty hood yawning wide beside the garage. He lifted his eyes toward me as I bounded to a stop and climbed up on the running board to get closer to his height.
Mother wants to take us on a picnic! By the ocean! She’s making sandwiches right now!
I was hanging by the chrome door handle, my voice rasped with excitement, my feet shifting one to another, bare toes pushing on bare toes as I waited for Ben’s reaction.
He smiled that Ben smile at me, no worse for the oil smudges on his cheek and brow. Sorry Bilbo, I got work to do. Gotta get this truck tuned up so I can get to the gig on Saturday night. He stuck his head back in the pistons and hoses leaving me stuck for words. I hadn’t seen that coming. As much as I wanted to go to the beach, the idea of a picnic with just my mother and me was not quite as appealing as the idea of Ben joining us, bringing his guitar to play on some grounded log.
C’mon Ben! You can do this later. It won’t be any fun if you don’t come!
He rubbed his hands on a cloth that was rumpled up on the battery as he slowly drew himself up and away from the truck, laughing at me as I fell to my knees on the scrub grass and clasped my hands toward him in prayer.
Tell you what. If you and your mother (Ben refused to call her Mother even after she was married to his Dad) can wait for an hour or so, I’ll get the oil changed, have a shower and give the truck a test drive out to the beach, O.K?
I jumped up and almost knocked him over with a hug, then ran back into the house to tell my mother.
Ben’s gonna come! Ben’s gonna come! I relayed Ben’s plan to my mother who looked up at the kitchen clock and said, Well that gives me time to make some cookies for us! Do you want to help me?
Now I was sure once again that aliens had had their way with my mother, but I wasn’t going to do anything to jeopardize this new-found interest in being with me. Sure!
What kind should we make?
Oatmeal raisin? She started rifling through the baking supply drawer and pulled out a bag of Hershey’s chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chip?
Chocolate chip cookies won the day and she let me measure, sift and stir and then she even let me crack the eggs! She hummed along to the radio, patiently showing me how to measure the butter, then the sugar. This was the first time we had ever cooked together and yet she made it seem like this was a daily event.
I was enjoying every minute of it. I loved cracking the eggs and letting the whites drip and pool, holding the electric beater so that it’s paddles clanked furiously against the metal bowl, spinning ingredients into the oven to bake, the aroma pulling Ben into the house like a willful genie. Mother slapped his grease-stained hands playfully as they made away with a cookie fresh from the oven on his way to the shower. Then she gave me one once he’d gone, winking at me, Sshhh! We’ll keep it between us girls!
Ben’s truck coughed a little now and then on the highway but by the time we turned off onto Rathtrevor Road it was running smooth as can be. I had heard of Rathtrevor Beach at school but this was the first time I’d been there. It was beautiful! Long strips of sand as far as I could see, fingers of water crossing in ripples and glimmers harboured sand-spitting clam-holes. Golden-white grasses surrounding ocean tossed sun bleached logs bade us picnickers welcome and mother set out the food on an old tablecloth as Ben took the Frisbee and guitar out of the back of the truck.
I kicked off my sandals and ran to the water’s edge, my feet celebrating in the sand and salt water. The beach was so flat you could walk for miles it seemed to me then, and still never be up to your waist in water. I looked back to wave at Mother and Ben, who were sitting on a blanket by a huge log, every few minutes, in between scooping up sand dollars and poking at starfish. A sturdy stick served to unearth baby clams, and sometimes huge horse clams were surprised, their long wrinkled necks flopping out like nothing I wanted to think about!
We ate while we watched the tide tug at the coastline, sea gulls, ravens vying for shallow prey, a soaking wet black lab grinning madly in full fleet, with what seemed like half a log sticking heavy out of his dripping mouth. Ben picked at his guitar in between bites of his tuna fish sandwich, his notes dispersing quickly in the open air and sea breeze. He and Mother shared a bottle of her homemade dandelion wine out of paper cups and I was happy because it seemed like finally they were getting along and we would be a family after all.
They were giggling about something when I came back with a bucket full of shells and pinecones my mother had sent me to get for her. I asked them what was so funny and they said it was the wine. Then they giggled again. I could see the bottle was empty and I knew Mother’s homemade wine could clean pitch off a window, so I was pretty sure it had done a bang up job on their brains. Mother was leaning back on the driftwood log and Ben was lying on his back with his guitar across his belly, his head resting by her hip, strumming distractedly.
I was getting tired, the sky was thickening and as much as I wanted our family to be close someday, this kind of closeness wasn’t what I had been picturing.
When are we goin’ home?
Oh honey, we’re gonna just stay here a bit, let our stomachs settle…
Ben’s eyes were closed against the afternoon sky but there was half a smile on his face as he handed me the Frisbee. Here Bilbo…go practice throwing this on the field over there and I’ll be over in awhile…His voice trailed off as I took the Frisbee, and sliding his guitar to the side he turned away and started to snore.
Go on, do like Ben says! My mother tried to sound crisp but the wine was setting up roadblocks on her lazy tongue.
Sometimes realization hits you like a brick, slap upside of your head and it hits so hard, so fast you’re spared the pain of it. Then there are those times that realization drips and seeps it’s way into your soul, tasteless, like a poison, numbing you, causing you to grimace, to smile and so smile I did as I headed out to the field to play Frisbee with myself.
The ride home was cold and quiet. I shivered. There was a weight in the air of the truck cab that was so dense I sensed one day it might crush us. Mother and Ben sat beside each other, staring straight ahead at the road and I leaned away into the locked door to be safe from them. Under the waking stars flickering in the bruised blue evening sky through the truck’s cracked windshield I weighed the situation carefully and being so very tired of it all, I chose to close my eyes.